An Analysis of Housing Policy Effectiveness in Indonesia Through Comparison Between Developed and Developing Countries’ Housing Policy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32890/jis2025.21.2.6Kata kunci:
Housing policy, affordable housing, policy comparison, developingAbstrak
This study examines Indonesia's challenges in meeting its citizens' housing needs amidst globalisation and economic liberalisation. The research aims to identify effective housing policies from developed and developing countries that can be adapted to the Indonesian context. Through a comparative analysis of housing policies in North Western Europe, the United States, Thailand, the Philippines, and Malaysia, the study explores different approaches to addressing housing affordability and accessibility. Findings reveal that developed countries leverage robust institutions and capital resources to implement tax and subsidy mechanisms, while developing countries face limitations due to financial constraints and low tax revenues. The study suggests that Indonesia can adopt successful policies from developed nations, such as targeted subsidies and incentivising private sector participation, while tailoring them to align with Indonesian values and socioeconomic conditions. This study examines Indonesia's challenges in meeting its citizens' housing needs amidst globalisation and economic liberalisation. The research aims to identify effective housing policies from developed and developing countries that can be adapted to the Indonesian context. Through a comparative analysis of housing policies in North Western Europe, the United States, Thailand, the Philippines, and Malaysia, the study explores different approaches to addressing housing affordability and accessibility. Findings reveal that developed countries leverage robust institutions and capital resources to implement tax and subsidy mechanisms, while developing countries face limitations due to financial constraints and low tax revenues. The study suggests that Indonesia can adopt successful policies from developed nations, such as targeted subsidies and incentivising private sector participation, while tailoring them to align with Indonesian values and socioeconomic conditions. This study reveals key differences in how developed and developing countries approach housing policy. While developed nations leverage strong institutions and significant capital for tax and subsidy programs to improve affordability and access, developing countries like Indonesia face limitations due to financial constraints and lower tax revenues. The research contributes valuable comparative analysis and policy recommendations for Indonesia, suggesting the adoption of targeted subsidies and incentivising private sector participation tailored to the country's unique context. Ultimately, it highlights the need for context-specific solutions to address housing challenges in a globalised world.
Rujukan
Akmal, A., Asriany, A., Bando, N., Mihrani, M., & Mariam, M. (2024). Examining the effects of technology adoption, cultural values, social capital, and government policies on entrepreneurial success and social impact in Indonesia. International Journal of Business, Law, and Education, 5(1), 431-449.
Alverdian, I. (2024). Indonesia’s maritime policy from independence to 2019: Political culture and maritime geography. Taylor & Francis.
Amador, M., & Bianchi, J. (2024). Bank runs, fragility, and credit easing. American Economic Review, 114(7), 2073-2110.
Anbinder, J. (2024). “Power to the neighborhoods!”: New York City growth politics, neighborhood liberalism, and the origins of the modern housing crisis. Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University.
Anenberg, E., & Ringo, D. (2024). Volatility in home sales and prices: Supply or demand? Journal of Urban Economics, 139, 103610.
Arista, S. M. (2024). Analisis struktur pasar industri perbankan umum konvensional di Indonesia tahun 2018-2022: Pendekatan struktural dan nonstruktural.
Badan Pusat Statistik. (2023). Statistik Indonesia 2023. Jakarta: Badan Pusat Statistik. https://www.bps.go.id/id/publication/2023/02/28/18018f9896f09f03580a614b/statistik-indone sia-2023.html
Batubara, B., Guntoro, Rachman, N. F., Herlily, & Adianto, J. (2024). Land occupation, re-occupation, and housing cooperative: Commune formation by Jakarta’s urban poor. Agrarian South: Journal of Political Economy, 13(1), 89-109.
Bozio, A., Garbinti, B., Goupille-Lebret, J., Guillot, M., & Piketty, T. (2024). Predistribution versus redistribution: Evidence from France and the United States. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 16(2), 31-65.
Broxterman, D. A., Liu, Y., & Yezer, A. M. (2024). Why we still do not know more about housing supply.
Cenzon, J., & Szabó, B. E. (2024). Mortgage choice and inflation experiences in the Eurozone. Journal of Monetary Economics, 103611.
Cook, C., Li, P., & Binder, A. (2024). Where to build affordable housing? Evaluating the tradeoffs of location.
Dehalwar, K., & Sharma, S. N. (2024). Exploring the distinctions between quantitative and qualitative research methods. Think India Journal, 27(1), 7-1.
Direktorat Jenderal Pembiayaan Perumahan. (2024). Tabungan perumahan rakyat. Kementerian Pekerjaan Umum dan Perumahan Rakyat. http://pembiayaan.pu.go.id/
Delladetsimas, P. Μ., Hiergens, I., Van den Broeck, P., & Moulaert, F. (2024). From Marxism to contemporary institutionalism in landed commons. In from land ownership to landed commons (pp. 48-83). Edward Elgar Publishing.
Deng, Y., Wachter, S. M., & Yoon, H. (2024). The American housing finance system: Structure, evolution, and implications. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4750853
Dezan Shira & Associates. (2023). An introduction to doing business in ASEAN 2023. Asia Briefing. https://www.asiabriefing.com/store/book/introduction-doing-business-asean.html
Fitriani, A., Prasetiyaningsih, E., Ameliyaningsih, T., Wahono, P., & Pahala, I. (2024). Overview of Indonesia’s tax ratio according to political agenda and comparison with another country. Moneter: Jurnal Keuangan dan Perbankan, 12(2), 244-249.
Fitzmaurice, K. P. (2024). The role of insurance, equity, and liquidity in the post-flood financial resilience of residential mortgage borrowers [Unpublished master's thesis]. The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Frei, D., & Ruloff, D. (2024). Handbook of foreign policy analysis: Methods for practical application in foreign policy planning, strategic planning and business risk assessment. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Frisvold, O. E., & Lægreid, E. E. (2024). Det beste alternativet for boligsparing [Unpublished master's thesis]. NTNU.
Garboden, P. M. (2024). You cannot get there from here: Mobility networks and the housing choice voucher program. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 44(3), 1257-1274.
Habibullah, H. (2024). Homelessness in the context of extreme poverty: Social policy from Indonesia. Homelessness to Hope, 365-384.
Hammad Ahmad Khan, H. (2024). The effects of housing price on the mortgage debt in Malaysia: New evidence from FMOLS method. International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis, 17(1), 60-78.
Harari, M., & Wong, M. (2024). Colonial legacy and land market Formality.
Harniwati, H. (2024). Hukum adat di era modernisasi. Journal of Global Legal Review, 2(1), 41-52.
Hartung, A. (2024). Does housing market segmentation ensure families a rental price benefit? The example of Frankfurt, Germany. Housing Studies, 39(3), 631–650.
Hewage, R., Pyeman, J., & Othman, N. (2024). Moderator effect of technological advancement on financial development and economic growth nexus in Asian countries. Journal of International Studies, 20(1), 115–147. https://doi.org/10.32890/jis2024.20.1.5
Ikhsan, D. M. F., Shukri, S., Mohamed Pero, S. D., & Norman, M. A. R. (2024). COVID-19 and capitalist structure: Evaluating of working-class inequality and policy effectiveness in Southeast Asia. Journal of International Studies, 20(2), 27–63. https://doi.org/10.32890/ jis2024.20.2.2
Irigaray, H. A. R., & Stocker, F. (2024). From Rostow to Raworth: A reflection on the solidarity economy. Cadernos EBAPE. BR, 22, e91378.
Kamata, T., & Kawakubo, S. (2024). Housing hierarchy of needs that contribute to the well-being of residents. In IOP conference series: Earth and environmental science, 1363(1), 012088.
Katadata Insight Center. (2022). Rumah untuk semua: Mewujudkan hunian yang layak dan terjangkau bagi seluruh rakyat Indonesia. Katadata.
Kimhur, B. (2024). Approach to housing justice from a capability perspective: bridging the gap between ideals and policy practices. Housing Studies, 39(2), 481–501.
Lister, R., Patrick, R., & Brown, K. (2024). Understanding theories and concepts in social policy. Policy Press.
McClure, K. (2024). Housing in the United States: The basics (Katrin B. Anacker). Routledge.
Meen, G. (2024). Neoclassical housing economics and beyond. In The Routledge Handbook of Housing Economics (pp. 15–26). Routledge.
Mehmet, O., & Yorucu, V. (2024). Land in economic theory. In from land disputes to sustainable environmental development: A near east perspective (pp. 5-23). Springer International Publishing.
Mietzner, M. (2024). The limits of autocratisation in Indonesia: Power dispersal and elite competition in a compromised democracy. Third World Quarterly, 1-17.
Monkkonen, P., Barrall, A., & Echavarria, A. (2024). Meaningful action: Evaluating local government plans to affirmatively further fair housing in California. Housing Policy Debate, 1-25.
Mulyadi, M., & Ubaidillah, N. Z. (2024). Unearthing the role of cultural perception in homeownership behavior: A conceptual exploration. Changing Societies & Personalities, 8(1), 202-221.
Nonaka, I., & Takeuchi, H. (2021). Humanizing strategy. Long Range Planning, 54(4).
Numbeo. (2024). Property Prices Index by Country 2024 Mid-Year. https://www.numbeo.com/ property-investment/rankings_by_country.jsp
Nurkhayati, F., & Fitrady, A. (2024). The impact of immigration on urban housing prices in Indonesia. International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis, 17(4), 964-977.
Oktora, S. I., Wulansari, I. Y., Siagian, T. H., Laksono, B. C., Sugiandewi, N. N. R., & Anindita, N. (2024). Identifying the potential participation in natural disaster insurance: First attempt based on a national socio-economic survey in Indonesia. International Journal of Disaster Resilience in the Built Environment, 15(2), 177-192.
Passmore, S. W., & Sparks, R. (2024). Government-sponsored mortgage securitization and financial crises. Finance and Economics Discussion Series 2024-002. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. https://doi.org/10.17016/FEDS.2024.002
Perdamaian, L. G., & Zhai, Z. (2024). Status of livability in Indonesian affordable housing. Architecture, 4(2), 281-302.
Piekut, M. (2024). Housing conditions in European one-person households. PLOS One, 19(5), e0303295.
Raksaka Mahi, B., & Resosudarmo, B. P. (2024). Regional public infrastructures and development in decentralized Indonesia. Applied Economics, 1-18.
Salam, S., Supardjo, S., & Nurlinda, I. (2024). The evolution of property rights in Indonesia. Journal of Indonesian Legal Studies, 9(1).
Setiawan, H. H., & Wismayanti, Y. F. (2024). Housing intervention for people who are homeless in Indonesia: Combining institutional and community-based approaches. Homelessness to hope (pp. 385-403). Elsevier.
Sururi, A. (2024). The effectiveness of housing finance policy innovation for low-income communities in Indonesia. Architecture and Urban Planning, 20(1), 28-39.
Shelby, H. (2024). Insurgent co‐production: Conflict, cooperation and the dialectics of scale in Thailand's Baan Mankong program. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 48(4), 666–688. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2427.13251
Smith, T. A., Brown, A., & Owen, J. (2024). Scaling low-income housing delivery in Kenya and the Philippines: Community participation and livelihoods outcomes. International Development Planning Review, 46(2), 123-149.
Sururi, A. (2024). The effectiveness of housing finance policy innovation for low-income communities in Indonesia. Architecture and Urban Planning, 20(1), 28-39.
Team HREIS. (2024). Laporan profil perumahan di Indonesia 2024 (Update). Kementerian Pekerjaan Umum dan Perumahan Rakyat. https://hreis.pu.go.id/portal/
Telaumbanua, E., Harsono, I., & Soegiarto, I. (2024). Urbanization in Indonesia: The relationship between income inequality, urban infrastructure, access to education, and population growth with social cohesion, environmental resilience, and housing quality to look at urbanization in Indonesia. International Journal of Business, Law, and Education, 5(1), 603-614.
Tudoroiu, T. (2024). A constructivist theoretical framework. In China’s two identities: Territorial empire and postmodern global power (pp. 13-57). Springer Nature Singapore.
Winarso, H. (2022). Slum-upgrading trough physical or socio-economic improvement? Lessons from Bandung, Indonesia. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 37(2), 863-88.
Zhai, P., Li, J., Lei, T., Zhu, J., & Novakovic, V. (2025). Indoor thermal comfort comparison between passive solar house with active solar heating and without active solar heating in Tibetan. Energy and Built Environment, 6(2), 285-296.
