BRITISH FOREIGN SECRETARY’S ROLE AND INFLUENCE IN THE EXCLUSION OF GREECE AND TÜRKIYE FROM NATO, 1948–1949
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32890/jis2023.19.2.6Keywords:
Bevin, Greco-Turkish, Cyprus issue, delays in NATO's creation, exclusionAbstract
When NATO was created on 4 April 1949 by the United States, Britain, Canada, and several Western European countries with the aim to
contain the Soviet Union’s expansion of power, it was rather peculiar that Greece and Türkiye were excluded, while their Mediterranean neighbour, Italy, was included in this new military organisation. As Greece suffered from the communist insurgents in the Greek Civil War (1946–1949), and Türkiye was unceasingly under Soviet military and diplomatic threat over the provinces of Kars and Ardahan and the Turkish Straits settlements (1946–1953), both seemingly had valid reasons for being included in NATO. However, Britain, one of the renowned founding members of NATO, determinedly repudiated to invite Greece and Türkiye to join NATO. This paper analyses the reasons for Britain to deny these countries NATO membership. The existing literature on this exclusion subject argues that the geographical location and the forthcoming Mediterranean Pact were two apparent causes that influenced Britain to reject Greece and Türkiye’s NATO membership. This paper however, investigates other rejection reasons that have yet to be studied by previous scholars. This paper offers an analysis of Britain’s objections to Greece and Türkiye’s NATO membership during NATO’s creation years through the study of British primary historical records. The finding shows that Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin was eager to have NATO promptly formed, and he believed the proposal for Greece and Türkiye’s inclusion in NATO would hamper this aim, since these two countries were in a dispute over Cyprus. Bevin reckoned that the bitter relationship between Greece and Türkiye over Cyprus would alarm the delegations, hence prolonging the discussions that would lead to further postponement of NATO’s ratification. Thus, Bevin’s démarche was not to propose the inclusion of Greece and Türkiye in NATO at the time.
References
Achilles, T. C. (1979). US Role in Negotiations that Led to Atlantic Alliance, Part 2. NATO Review, 16-19.
Athanassopoulou, E. (1996). Western Defence Developments and Turkey’s Search for Security in 1948. Middle Eastern Studies, 32, 77-108.
Athanassopoulou, E. (2012). Turkey – Anglo-American Security Interests, 1945-1952: The First Enlargement of NATO. London: Frank Cass.
Baharçiçek, A. (2010). From Neutrality to Alignment: The Formation of NATO. Journal of Academic Approaches, 1, 57-68.
Baylis, J. (1993). The Diplomacy of Pragmatism: Britain and the Formation of NATO, 1942-1949. Ohio: Kent State University Press.
Binder, D. (2012). Greece, Turkey and NATO. Mediterranean Quarterly, 23, 95-106.
Boyle, P. G. (1990). America’s Hesitant Road to NATO, 1945-49. In J. Smith (Ed.), The Origins of NATO (pp. 65-81). Exeter: University of Exeter Press.
CAB129/23. (1948). Memorandum by the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs: The First Aim of British Foreign Policy, 4 January 1948. London: The National Archives.
CAB131/1. (1946). Reports by Chancellor of the Exchequer: Britain’s Economic Burden, 11 January 1946. London: The National Archives.
CAB133/86. (1946, April 20). Chiefs of Staff to the Defence Committee. London: The National Archives.
Crawshaw, N. (1978). The Cyprus Revolt: An Account of the Struggle for Union with Greece. London: George Allen & Unwin.
Department of State. (1949). Memorandum signed by Acheson: Conversation with Senators Connally, George and Vandenberg (file No. 840.20/2-2849). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Dockrill, M. L., & Hopkins, M. F. (2006). The Cold War 1945-91. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
FO371/67276/R11125. (1947). Sir Noel Charles (the British Ambassador to Turkey) to Foreign Office, 7 August 1947. London: The National Archives.
FO371/67276/R11126. (1947). Foreign Office to the British Embassy in Rome, 12 September 1947. London: The National Archives.
FO371/68067/AN1274. (1948). Atlantic Security: Conversation with Norwegian Minister for Foreign Affairs, 15 March 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/68067/AN1276. (1948). Atlantic Security Talks: First meeting of Group, 22 to 24 March 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/68068A/AN1437. (1948). Atlantic Security Talks: movements of Mr Jebb’, From Washington to Foreign Office, 31 March 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/68068A/AN1412. (1948). Atlantic Security Talks: proposed message to Mr Marshall’, From Washington to Foreign Office, 31 March 1948. London: The National Archives.
TNA, FO 371/68068A/AN1547. (1948). Atlantic Security, From Washington to Foreign Office, 10 April 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/68068A/AN1666. (1948). Atlantic Security: Proposed Conference 22 April 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/71458. (1948). Foreign Office to Washington: Establishment of an Atlantic Security System, 10 March 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/72534. (1948). Sir D. Kelly to Foreign Office, 28 January 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/72535/R12342. (1948). Foreign Office to Angora: Conversation in Paris between Turkish Minister of Foreign Affairs and Mr Roberts, 29 October 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/72535/R13293. (1948). Sir D. Kelly (Ankara) to Mr C.H. Bateman (Foreign Office): Visit of Professor TOYNBEE to Turkey – account of interview with Turkish President, 17 November 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/72535/R13409. (1948). Angora to Foreign Office: Turkish request for inclusion in the Atlantic pact, 26 November 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/73045. (1948). Washington to Foreign Office: The Western Union – Conversation with Mr Hickerson. 21 January 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/73070/Z4673. (1948). Washington to Foreign Office: Security Talks, 14 June 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO 371/73072/Z5616. (1948). Security Talks: Meeting on July 6th, From Foreign Office to Washington, 13 July 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/73073. (1948). Washington Exploratory Talks on Security: Fourth meeting – Security Relations with Other Western European Countries, 8 July 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/73075/Z6947. (1948). Atlantic Security Pact: conversation between Mr Jebb and M. Chauvel in Paris on August 23rd’, Foreign Office minute, Mr Jebb, Top Secret, 23 August 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/73075/Z6999. (1948). Atlantic Security Pact: conversation between Mr JEBB and M. SCHUMANN on August 24th, Foreign Office minute, Mr Jebb, Top Secret, 24 August 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO371/73081/Z9294. (1948). Report by U.K. Representative on Permanent Commission on recent negotiations regarding an Atlantic Pact, Top Secret, Z 8974/2307/G, Sir Paul Mason (Foreign Office official) for the Secretary of State (Bevin) to Mr Gladwyn Jebb, 6 November 1948. The National Archives.
FO371/78328/R1843. (1949). Turkish Minister for Foreign Affairs (conversation): Turkish interest in proposed North Atlantic Pact (Record of conversation with S of S) No. 26, 14 February 1949. London: The National Archives.
FO371/78328/R581. (1949). Foreign Office minute by Mr Russell: Greece and the Atlantic Pact (Record of conversation with M. MOSTRAS [Greek Embassy], 28 January 1949. London: The National Archives.
FO371/79221. (1949). Washington to Foreign Office: North Atlantic Pact – Meeting of Washington Working Party on January 10, 10 January 1949. London: The National Archives.
FO371/79225. (1949). Washington to Foreign Office: Minutes of the Twelfth Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks on Security, February 8, 15 February 1949. London: The National Archives.
FO371/79228/Z1741. (1949). North Atlantic Pact: Canadian attitude regarding Article II, From Foreign Office to Washington, 24 February 1949. London: The National Archives.
FO800/448. (1949). Record of Meeting on Thursday: 27th January 1949, at 10:30 A.M. (Full Session). London: The National Archives.
FO800/454/Def-69. (1948). Washington Exploratory Talks on Security: Ninth Meeting, 13 December 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO800/454/Def-71. (1948). Washington Exploratory Talks on Security: Tenth Meeting, 22 December 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO800/454/Def-72. (1948). Sir Oliver Franks to Secretary of State Bevin, 29 December 1948. London: The National Archives.
FO800/502/Part2. (1948). Review on the situation in Turkey: Eastern Mediterranean Bloc, 28 July 1948. London: The National Archives.
Folly, M. H. (1988). Breaking the Vicious Circle: Britain, the United States and the Genesis of the North Atlantic Treaty. Diplomatic History, 12 , 59-77.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 61. Minutes of the First Meeting of the United States-United Kingdom-Canada Security Conversations, 22 March 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 65. Minutes of the Second Meeting of the United States-United Kingdom-Canada Security Conversations, Held at Washington, 23 March 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 66. Minutes of the Third Meeting of the United States-United Kingdom-Canada Security Conversations, 24 March 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 139. The Secretary of State to the Embassy in France, 24 June 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS, 1948, Western Europe, Vol. III, pp. 148-182. Minutes of the First Meeting to the Fifth Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks on Security, July 6 to July 9, 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS, 1948, Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 149, Minutes of the First Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks on Security, 6 July 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 165. Minutes of the Fourth Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks on Security, 8 July 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, pp. 285-286, Memorandum by the Director of the Policy Planning Staff (Kennan), ‘Enclosure: Considerations Affecting the Conclusion of a North Atlantic Security Pact – 2. The territorial scope of the pact’, 24 November 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, pp. 294-295. The Ambassador in Turkey (Wadsworth) to the Secretary of State, 26 November 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 317. Minutes of the Ninth Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks on Security. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 321. Memorandum by the Director of the Office of Near Eastern and African Affairs (Satterthwaite) to the Under Secretary of State (Lovett), 14 December 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 328, Minutes of the Tenth Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks, 22 December 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, pp. 330-331. Minutes of the Tenth Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks, 22 December 1948. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1948). Western Europe, Vol. III, p. 331. Minutes of the Tenth Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks, 22 December 1948. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1949). Western Europe, Vol. IV, p. 5. Memorandum of Conversation, by the Counselor of the Department of State (Bohlen), 3 January 1949. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1949). Western Europe, Vol. IV, pp. 27-28, Minutes of the Eleventh Meeting of the Washington Exploratory Talks on Security, 14 January 1949. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
FRUS. (1949). Western Europe, Vol. IV, pp. 175-176. Memorandum by the Director of the Office of Near Eastern and African Affairs (Satterthwaite) to the Secretary of State, ‘Subject: Declaration on Greece, Turkey and Iran’, 8 March 1949. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Gheciu, A. (2005). NATO in the “New Europe”: The Politics of International Socialization after the Cold War. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.
Gonlubol, M. (1975). NATO, USA and Turkey. In K. H. Karpat (Ed.), Turkey’s Foreign Policy in Transition 1950-1974 (pp. 13-50). Leiden: E. J. Brill.
Hatzivassiliou, E. (1997). Britain and the International Status of Cyprus, 1955–59. United States of America: University of Minnesota.
Hussain, N. (2018). British Foreign Office Perspectives on the Admission of Turkey and Greece to NATO, 1947-1952. PhD thesis. University of Leeds.
Hussain, N. (2022). The Origin of U.S. Containment Policy in 1947: The Perception of British School. Tamkang Journal of International Affairs, 53-116.
Joseph, J. S. (1999). Cyprus: Ethnic Conflict and International Politics: From Independence to the Threshold of the European Union. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
McGhee, G. C. (1990). The US-Turkish-NATO Middle East Connection: How the Truman Doctrine and Turkey’s NATO Entry Contained the Soviets. Basingstoke: The Macmillan Press Ltd.
PREM8/1379/Part 1/2629. (1949). Foreign Office to Washington, 7 March 1949. London: The National Archives.
PREM8/1379/Part 1/3042. (1949). Foreign Office to Washington, 17 March 1949. London: The National Archives.
Reid, E. (1977). Time of Fear and Hope: The Making of the North Atlantic Treaty, 1947-1949. Toronto: McClelland and Steward.
Rubin, B. (1980). The Great Powers in the Middle East 1941-1947: The Road to the Cold War . London: Frank Cass and Company Limited.
Smith, M. (2000). NATO Enlargement during the Cold War: Strategy and System in the Western Alliance. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Stearns, M. (1992). Entangled Allies: U.S. Policy Toward Greece, Turkey, and Cyprus. New York: Council on Foreign Relations Press.
