REVISING THE UNITARY VS. FEDERAL CLASSIFICATION

Authors

  • Zuriana Zahrin School of Government, University Utara Malaysia
  • Ahmad Martadha Mohamed School of Government, University Utara Malaysia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.32890/jis2022.18.5

Keywords:

Unitary, Federation, Classification, Regionalization, Decentralisation

Abstract

Over the last four decades, the distinction between unitary and federation systems has become increasingly blurred, as regionalization and decentralization have emerged as significant global trends. Regionalization and decentralization are responsible for redistribution of power across borders and for strengthening broader society's subnational capacity and function. Both have indirectly facilitated the expansion of "federalization processes" within unitary states. As a result, distinguishing between unitary and federated territorial management and power-sharing arrangements is difficult. This "intermediate system" was an apparently novel form of territorial division of power that was never classified as an incomplete federation or an evolutionary type of unitary system. This indicates that the unitary vs. federation dichotomy is becoming incongruous and that the existing classification is no longer relevant. As a result, this article revises the unitary-federal classification based on developments in n=70 selected countries from 1970 to 2018, as measured by the Regional Authority Index, an annual data series. To classify countries into clusters, the data index was analyzed using hybrid clustering analysis with k-means clustering as the primary analysis. Initially, inferential analysis performed suggested the establishment of four clusters (k=4). However, the clustering together of unitary and federated countries resulted in re-clustering, leading to the formation of five new clusters.

References

Akindele, S. T., & Olaopa, O. R. (2003). The theory and practice of federalism as a structural mechanism of governance: how adequate for gender struggle and representation in Nigeria? Anthropologist, 5(3), 169-178.

Anderson, G. (2010). Federalism and Africa. Federations, December 2010/January 2011, 9.

Bahl, R. (2006). Fiscal decentralisation. Atlanta: Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, Georgia State University.

Bailey, K. D. (1994). Typologies and taxonomies: an introduction to classification techniques. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage Publications, Inc.

Baldi, B. (1999). Beyond the federal-unitary dichotomy. Working Papers. University of California. Retrieved from http://www.escholarship.org/uc/item/05b607ng

Bagchi, A. (2003). Rethinking federalism: changing power relations between the centre and the states. Publius, 33(4), 21-42.

Bickerton, J., & Gagnon, A.-G. (2014). Regions. In D. Caramani (Ed.), Comparative politics (3rd. ed., pp. 252-268). New York: Oxford University Press.

Bird, R. M., & Vaillancourt, F. (1999). Fiscal decentralisation in developing countries: An overview. In R. M. Bird & F. Vaillancourt (Eds.), Fiscal decentralisation in developing countries. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press..

Bowman, A. O. M., & Kearney, R. C. (1996). State and local government (3rd ed.). Boston: Hughton Mifflin Company.

Braun, D. (2000). Territorial division of power and public policy-making: an overview. In D. Braun (Ed.), Public Policy and Federalism (pp. 1-26). Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing Limited.

Burgess, M. (1993). Federalism and federation: a reappraisal. In M. Burgess & A.-G. Gagnon (Eds.), Comparative federalism and federation: competing traditions and future directions (pp. 3-14). London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Burgess, M. (2006). Comparative federalism: theory and practice. New York: Routledge.

Cheema, G. S., & Rondinelli, D. A. (2007). Decentralizing governance: concepts and practices. In. Retrieved from http://site.ebrary.com/lib/uum/Doc?id=10176637&ppg=12.

Douence, J.-C. (1995). The evolution of the 1982 regional reforms: An overview. In J. Loughlin & S. Mazey (Eds.), The end of the French unitary state? Ten years of regionalization in France (1982-1992) (pp. 10-24). London: Frank Cass & Co. Ltd.

Ebel, R. D., & Yilmaz, S. (2001). Concept of fiscal decentralisation and worldwide overview. Paper presented at the International Symposium Québec Commission on Fiscal Imbalance, Québec City, Québec. http://www.desequilibrefiscal.gouv.qc.ca/en/pdf/ebel.pdf

Elaigwu, J. I. (2010). Federal systems not new to Africa. Federations, 10-12.

Elazar, D. J. (1982). Federalism, centralization, and state building in the modern epoch. Publius, 12(3), 1-9.

Elazar, D. J. (1987). Exploring federalism. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.

Elazar, D. J. (1997). Contrasting Unitary and Federal Systems. International Political Science Review / Revue internationale de science politique, 18(3), 237-251. doi:10.2307/1601342

Emiliani, N., Lugaresi, S., & Ruggiero, E. (1997). Part II: Practice-Industrial countries: Italy. In T. Ter-Minassian (Ed.), Fiscal federalism in theory and practice (pp. 249-284). Washington: International Monetary Fund.

Evered, K. T. (2005). Regionalism in the Middle East and the case of Turkey. Geographical Review, 95(3), 463-477. doi:10.2307/30034248

Finer, H. (1970). Theory and practice of modern government. Connecticut: Greenwood Press.

Gaskin, J. (2015, Jun 24). Two step cluster analysis scatter plot SPSS. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YCZLMf7g42Y&list=PLmqaxZWCCEozRnFsWWpSVq DC 8S98BM4aa&index=2

Hair, J. F., Black, B., Babin, B., Anderson, R. E., & Tatham, R. L. (2010). Multivariate data analysis: A global perspective (7th ed.). New Jersey, USA: Pearson Education Inc.

Hooghe, L., Marks, G., Schakel, A. H., Niedzwiecki, S., Osterkatz, S. C. and Shair-Rosenfield, S. (2016). Measuring regional authority: A postfunctionalist theory of governance. Vol I. United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.

Kavalski, E., & Zolkos, M. (2008). Approaching the phenomenon of federal failure. In E. Kavalski & M. Zolkos (Eds.), Defunct Federalisms: Critical Perspectives on Federal Failure (pp. 1-16). Abingdon, Oxon, GBR Ashgate Publishing Group

King, P. (1982). Federalism and federation. London: Croom Helm.

King, P. (1993). Federation and representation. In M. Burgess & A.-G. Gagnon (Eds.), Comparative federalism and federation (pp. 94-101). New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Kreppel, A. (2008). Legislatures. In D. Caramani (Ed.), Comparative Politics (pp. 159-188). New York: Oxford University Press.

Lijphart, A. (1984). Democracies. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Lijphart, A. (1999). Patterns of democracy: government forms and performance in thirty-six countries. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.

Loughlin, J. (1996). "Europe of the regions" and the federalization of Europe. Publius, 26(4), 141-162. doi:10.2307/3330775

Loughlin, J. (2014). Federal and local government institutions. In D. Caramani (Ed.), Comparative politics (3rd. ed., pp. 181-196). New York: Oxford University Press.

Livingston, W. S. (1952). A Note on the Nature of Federalism. Political Science Quarterly, 67(1), 81-95. doi:10.2307/2145299

Oates, W. E. (2006). On the Theory and Practice of Fiscal Decentralisation. In: Institute for Federalism & Intergovernmental Relations (IFIR). Working Paper Series No. 2006-05.

Regmi, K., Naidoo, J., Greer, A., & Pilkington, P. (2010). Understanding the effect of decentralisation on health services: the Nepalese experience. Journal of Health Organization and Management, 24(4), 361-382. doi:10.1108/14777261011064986

Riker, W. H. (1964). Federalism: Origin, operation, significance. Little Brown: Boston.

Rodden, J. (2003). Reviving leviathan: fiscal federalism and the growth of government. International Organization, 57, 695-729.

Rodden, J. (2004). Comparative federalism and decentralisation: on meaning and measurement. Comparative Politics, 36(4), 481-500.

Shobha, K., (2020, March 28). How to do hierarchical clustering SPSS. [Video] YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMKfdfDuEDE&lst=PLmqaxZWCCEoxdLeaVlFzqtrcuu bc5m XEk&index=8&t=270s

Schrijver, F. (2006). Regionalism After Regionalisation: Spain, France and the United Kingdom. Amsterdam, NLD: Amsterdam University Press.

Swenden, W. (2006). Federalism and regionalism in Western Europe: A comparative and thematic analysis. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Taghavi-Dinani, M. (1982). Federalism: A comparative and analytical study. (PhD), University Microfilms International, An Arbor Michigan, USA. .

Verney, D. V. (1995). Federalism, federative systems and federations: The United States, Canada, and India. Publius, 25(2), 81-97.

Visser, J. D. (2010). Lessons learned from Africa. Federations, 27-29.

Volden, C. (2004). Origin, operation, and significance: the federalism of William H. Riker. Publius, 34(4), 89-107.

Watts, R. L. (1998). Federalism, federal, political systems and federations. Annual Reviews Political Science, 1, 117-137.

Watts, R. L. (Ed.) (1999). Comparing federal systems (2nd ed.). London: McGill-Queen's University Press.

Yao, G. A. (2006). Fiscal decentralisation and poverty reduction outcomes: theory and evidence. (Doctoral Dissertation), Georgia State University.

Wheare, K. C. (1963). Federal government (4th ed.). London: Oxford University Press.

Additional Files

Published

2022-10-16