Incumbency Factor, Internal Party Democracy and Democratic Consolidation in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic

Alfa Patrick  Innocent; Kamarul Zaman  Haji Yusoff; Sivaperegasam  P. Rajanthiran

doi:10.32890/jgd2017.13.2.5

Pengarang

Alfa Patrick Innocent Universiti Utara Malaysia, Malaysia
Kamarul Zaman Haji Yusoff Universiti Utara Malaysia, Malaysia
Sivaperegasam P. Rajanthiran Universiti Utara Malaysia, Malaysia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.32890/jgd2017.13.2.5

Kata kunci:

Incumbency, internal party democracy, election, democratic consolidation, Nigeria

Abstrak

The objective of this paper is to interrogate the nexus between incumbency
factor, internal party democracy and democratic consolidation in Nigeria’s
Fourth Republic. Abundance evidence suggest that Incumbency factor and
internal party democracy exercise monumental influence on the growth of
democracy in Nigeria.
The paper adopts a conceptual and qualitative methodology. The researcher
collected the data through the secondary sources. Thus, relevant materials
including textbooks, journal articles, party constitutions and the 1999
constitution of Nigeria were consulted in the quest to establish the linkages.
The assertion was substantiated and buttressed by the data. The research
unveiled that abuse of incumbency advantage and lack of internal party
democracy constitute major drawbacks to democratic consolidation in
Nigeria.
Adducing convincing evidence, the paper established `the relationship between
incumbency factor, internal party democracy and democratic consolidation
in Nigeria. The paper is particularly imperative for stakeholders in Nigeria’s
democratic experience as it would make them to be conscious and refrain
from abuse of incumbency and adhere to the doctrines of internal party
democracy in order to fast track democratic growth and consolidation in
Nigeria.

Rujukan

Abramowitz, A. I. (1989). “Campaign Spending in U.S Senate Elections”. Legislative Studies Quarterly 14: 487-507.

Abramowitz, A. I. (1991). “ Incumbency Campaign Spending and the Decline of Competition in U. S House Elections”. The Journal of Politics. 53: 34-56.

Adeniyi, O. (2017). Against the Run of Play: How an Incumbent president was defeated in Nigeria. Nigeria: Kachifo Limited.

Agbaje, A and Adejumobi, S (2006) Do Votes Count? The Travails of Electoral Politics in Nigeria. Africa Development pp24-44.

Alfa, P.I and Momoh, A.A (2011) The Albatross Called Incumbency Factor and the Challenges of Democratization in Nigeria. Journal of Policy and Development Studies 5(2) pp 170-175.

Akinloye, L (2016) Nigeria’s once mighty PDP is fighting for the future. Nigeria: African Argument.

Akinyele, T.A (2004) The 2003 Elections in Nigeria: Views from a policymaker. Africa Update Newsletter. Nigeria, Vol.X1Issue 4.

Ansolabehere,S and Snyder, J.M (2002) The Incumbency Advantange in U.S Elections: An Analysis of State and Federal Offices 1942-2000. Election Law Journal 1(3): 315-338.

Ansolabehere,S, Hirano,S, Snyder, J.M and Ueda, M (2006) Party and Incumbency Cues in Voting Are They Substitutes? Quarterly Journal of Political Science 1(4) 393-404.

Azeez, A (2009) Ethnicity, Party Politics and Democracy in Nigeria: Peoples’ Democratic Party (PDP) as agent of Consolidation? Journal of Tribes Tribals 7 (1): 1-9.

Banks, J.S and Sundaram, R.K (1998) Optimal Retention in Agency Problems. Journal of Economic Theory 82 (2) 293-323.

Besley, T (2006) Principal Agent? The Political Economy of Good Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Birch, S (2011) Electoral Malpractice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bueno de, M and Lander, D (2008) The Equilibrium Theory of Clarity Responsibility. University of Chicago Mimeo.

Cain, B, Ferejohn, J and Fiorina, M (1987) The Personal Vote: Constituency Service and Electoral Independence. Cambridge, MA: Havard University Press. Carson, J et al (eds) (2015) Assessing the Rise and Development of the Incumbency Advantage in Congress: Paper presented at the congress and History Conference held at Vanderbilt University, May 22-23.

Cox, G. W and Katz, J. N (1996) Why Did the Incumbency Advantage in U.S House Elections Grown?”American Journal of Political Science, 40: 478-497.

Diamond, L (1994) Political Culture and Democracy in Developing Countries. Boulder Co and London: Lynne and Rienner. Diamond, L (ed) (1997) Transition Without End. Lynne and Rienner: U.S.A.

Dode, O. R (2010) Political Parties and the Prospects of Democratic Consolidation in Nigeria: 1999-2006. African Journal of Political Science and International Relations. Vol. 4 (5) pp 188-194.

Erikson, R.S (1971) “The Advantage of Incumbency in Congressional Elections”. Polity 3: 395-405.

Ferejohn, J.A (1977) “On the Decline of Competition in Congressional Elections”. American Political Science Review, 71: 166-176.

Ferejohn, J (1986) Incumbent Performance and Electoral Control. Public Choice 50(1) 5-26.

Fiorina, M.P (1977) “ The Case of the Vanishing Marginals: The Bureaucracy Did It”. American Political Science Review. 71:177-181.

Gander, K (2015) Nigeria Election 2015: Muhammed Buhari wins in historical presidential election. Independent, Tuesday 31, retrieved from www.independent.co.uk/world/africa/nigeria-2015-electionapc-declares-victory-muhammadu-buhari-10146740.html.

Gordon, S.C, Huber,G and Lander,D (2009) “Voter Responses to Challenger Opportunity Costs”. Electoral Studies 28 (1): 79-93.

Gordon, S.C and Landa, D (2009) Do the Advantages of Incumbency Advantage Incumbents? The Journal of Politics Vol. 71 (4) 14811498.

Godliffe, J (2005) When Do War Chests Deter? Journal of Theoretical Politics 17(2) 249-277.

Grossman, G and Helpman, E (1999) Competing for Endorsement. American Economic Review 89(3) 501-524.

Gunther, F, Diamondourous, E and Puhle, H (1995) the Politics of Democratic Consolidation: Southern European in Comparative Perspective. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press.

Hill, T.J (2003) Interest-ing Candidates: The Electoral Impact of Interest Group Endorsements. PhD Dissertation, Ohio State University.

Ikpe, U.B (2013) Godfatherism and the Nigerian Polity in A.S Obiyan and

K. Amuwo (2013) Nigeria’s Democratic Experience in the Fourth Republic since 1999: Policies and Politics. U.S.A: University Press of America Inc.

Iliffe, J (2011) Obasanjo, Nigeria and the World. Oxford: James Currey.

International IDEA (2000) Democracy in Nigeria: Continuing Dialogue(s) for Nation-Building; Capacity-Building Series, No. 10.

Jacobson, G.C (2015) “ It’s Nothing Personal: The Decline of Incumbency Advantage in Congressional Election”. Journal of Politics 3: 1-10.

Jaja, N and Alumona, M (2011) Incumbency Factor and Democratic Consolidation in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic. Social Sciences Vol. 6 (2) 125-130.

Jibrin, I (2007) Nigeria’s 2007 Elections: The Fitful Path to Democratic Citizenship. Special Report by the United States Institute of Peace. Washington D.C. Jibrin, I and Egwu, S (eds) (2005) Nigeria Elections: Defending the Peoples’ Mandate. Abuja: Global Rights.

Isumonah, V. A (2012) Imperial Presidency and Democratic Consolidation in Nigeria. Africa Today, 43-68.

Joseph, R.A (1987) Democracy and Prebendal Politics in Nigeria: The Rise and fall of the Second Republic. Ibadan: Spectrum.

Katsina, A. M (2013) A Contextual Analysis of Party System Formation in Nigeria, 1960-2011. Intellectual Discourse 21(2)

Kayode, F (2013) Between S.L Akintola and Obafemi Awolowo. Nigeria: Premium Times. Keller, E (n.d) Beyond Autocracy in Oyediran, O and Agbaje, A (1991) Two Partyism and Democratic Transition in Nigeria. Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol.29 (2) 213-235.

Kwasau, M.M (2013) the Challenges of Democratic Consolidation in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic. European Scientific Journal, Vol. 9 (8).

Lazarus, J (2008) Why Do Experienced Challengers Do Better than Amateurs? Political Behaviour 30 (2) 185-198.

Mayhew, D.R (1974) Congressional Elections: The Case of the Vanishing Marginals. Polity, 6(3): 295-317.

Mbah, P (2011) Party Defection and Democratic Consolidation in Nigeria, 1999-2009. Afro-Asian Journal of Social Science 2(3), 1-21.

McKelvey, R.D and Ordeshook (1985) Sequential Elections with Limited Information. American Journal of Political Science 29 (3) 480-513.

McKelvey, R.D and Riezman, R (1992) Seniority in Legislature. American Political Science Review 86 (4) 951-965. Nzongola, N and Lee, M.C (eds) (n.d) The State and Democracy in Africa. Harare: AAPS Books.

Ojuogbo, C (2015) Jonathan Lost Because He Breached Zoning Arrangement. Nigeria: The Herald, July 12.

Okhaide, I.P (2012) Quest for Internal Party Democracy in Nigeria: Amendment of Electoral Act 2010 as an Albatross. International Journal of Peace and Development Studies, Vol. 3(3) 57-75.

Osaghe, E (2000) Crippled Giant: Nigeria since Independence. London: Hurst.

Report of the Political Bureau (1987). Abuja: MAMSER.

Report of the Commonwealth Observer Group (2015) Nigeria Presidential and National Assembly Elections 2015. U.K: Commonwealth.

Oyediran, O and Agbaje, a (1991) Two Partyism and Democratic Transition in Nigeria. Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol.29 (2) 213-235.

Schmitter, P.C (1992) the Consolidation of Consolidation of Democracy and Representation of Social Groups. American Behavioural Scientist, 35: 16.

Tenuche, M.S (2011) The Albatross called Primary Elections and Political Succession in Nigeria. Canadian Social Science Vol. 7(4) 121-130.

TMG (2007) An Election Programmed to Fail: Final Report of the April 2007 General Elections in Nigeria. Abuja: Transition Monitoring Group.

Wittman, D (2007) Candidate quality, pressure group endorsements and the nature of political advertising. European Journal of Political Economy 23(2) 360-378.